In enforcement proceedings by attachment based on a negotiable instrument (promissory note, bill of exchange or cheque; kambiyo senedi), the debtor may object to the payment order only by applying to the enforcement court (icra mahkemesi) within 5 days; the 7-day objection period of ordinary attachment proceedings does not apply. Objections concerning the debt, the signature or the status of the document as a negotiable instrument are filed by petition with the enforcement court, not the enforcement office, and an objection does not by itself stop the proceedings except for the sale (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code (İcra ve İflas Kanunu, İİK) Arts. 168–170/a).
- Payment period: the debt and enforcement costs must be paid within 10 days (İİK Art. 168/2).
- Objection period: 5 days for a complaint, an objection to the signature and an objection to the debt (İİK Art. 168/3, 4, 5).
- Forum: the enforcement court; the petition is not filed with the enforcement office.
- Effect: the objection does not stop the proceedings other than the sale; the judge may order a temporary stay.
- Grounds for objecting to the debt are limited: no debt owed, payment (itfa), grace period (mehil), limitation and jurisdiction.
- Sanctions: an unjustified objection may lead to compensation and a fine.
What is enforcement by attachment specific to negotiable instruments?
A creditor whose claim rests on a cheque, bill of exchange or promissory note (emre muharrer senet, bono) may, even if the claim is secured by a pledge, proceed under the special provisions of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code (İİK) either by attachment or, if the debtor is subject to bankruptcy, by bankruptcy proceedings (İİK Art. 167). The creditor must attach to the enforcement request the original instrument and a certified copy for each debtor.
In this type of proceeding, if the enforcement officer sees that the document is a negotiable instrument and that it has fallen due, a payment order is sent to the debtor immediately. The notable differences from ordinary attachment proceedings are the short objection periods and the fact that objections are made to the enforcement court rather than the enforcement office.
What periods does the payment order give the debtor?
Under İİK Art. 168 the payment order states the following:
- The debt and costs must be paid to the enforcement office's bank account within 10 days;
- If the document is not a negotiable instrument, a complaint must be filed with the enforcement court within 5 days;
- If the signature on the instrument is not the debtor's, this must be notified by petition to the enforcement court within 5 days;
- Claims that no debt is owed, that the debt was paid, that a grace period was granted, that the claim is time-barred or that the enforcement office lacks jurisdiction must be submitted to the enforcement court with reasons within 5 days;
- If no objection is made and the debt is not paid, a declaration of assets must be made within 10 days; if an objection is made and rejected, within 3 days.
The five-day period is understood to run from service of the payment order. If it is missed, enforcement continues; if no objection to the signature is made, the signature is deemed to be the debtor's.
Which remedies are available to the debtor?
1. Complaint: the document is not a negotiable instrument
If the document underlying the proceedings lacks the elements required by law, the debtor may file a complaint under İİK Arts. 168/3 and 170/a. The elements of a promissory note are listed in Turkish Commercial Code (Türk Ticaret Kanunu, TTK) Art. 776: the term “promissory note” (bono) or “note payable to order”, an unconditional promise to pay a specific sum, the maturity date, the place of payment, the name of the payee, the date and place of issue, and the issuer's signature. A document lacking one of these elements is, as a rule, not a promissory note (TTK Art. 777); for some omissions, such as maturity, place of issue and place of payment, the law provides supplementary rules. Even without a complaint, if the enforcement court sees from the file that the document is not a negotiable instrument or that the creditor has no right to proceed under these provisions, it may annul the proceedings of its own motion (İİK Art. 170/a).
2. Objection to the signature
If the signature on the instrument is not the debtor's, this claim is submitted to the enforcement court by petition within 5 days (İİK Art. 170). If the objection is considered serious, the judge may order a temporary stay of the proceedings on the file before the hearing. If the signature is found to be the debtor's and the proceedings had been stayed, the debtor is ordered to pay denial compensation (inkâr tazminatı) of at least 20% of the claim and a fine of 10%.
3. Objection to the debt
The debtor submits, by petition to the enforcement court within 5 days and with reasons, that no debt is owed, that the debt was paid, that a grace period was granted, that the claim is time-barred, or an objection to jurisdiction (İİK Arts. 168/5, 169). Unlike ordinary attachment proceedings, not every defence can be raised at this stage; the grounds are limited.
The enforcement judge summons the parties to a hearing within 30 days at the latest. For the objection to be accepted, the absence or payment of the debt must be proved by an official document or a document whose signature has been acknowledged (İİK Art. 169/a). Witnesses or ordinary correspondence are therefore not enough; a bank receipt showing payment or a receipt signed by the creditor, for example, is important in this respect.
If the documents attached to the debtor's petition show that the debt was paid, that the claim is time-barred on the face of the instrument, or that no debt is owed, the judge may temporarily stay the proceedings until the decision on the merits of the objection.
Does an objection stop the enforcement?
No; neither the objection to the debt nor the objection to the signature stops enforcement actions other than the sale (İİK Arts. 169/1 and 170/1). Assets may therefore be attached, but they cannot be sold unless the judge orders a temporary stay. If the objection is accepted, the proceedings stop; the creditor keeps the right to sue under the general rules. An appeal (istinaf) against a decision rejecting the objection does not stop any enforcement action; enforcement stops only if the debtor provides security under İİK Art. 33/3 (last paragraph of İİK Art. 169/a).
What are the sanctions for an unjustified objection or enforcement?
- Objection to the debt accepted: if the creditor acted in bad faith or with gross fault, compensation of at least 20% of the claim is awarded (İİK Art. 169/a).
- Objection to the debt rejected: if the proceedings had been temporarily stayed, the debtor may be ordered to pay compensation of at least 20% of the claim.
- Objection to the signature: if the signature is found to be the debtor's, 20% denial compensation and a 10% fine; if the objection is accepted and the creditor acted in bad faith or with gross fault, at least 20% compensation and a 10% fine apply to the creditor as well (İİK Art. 170).
Collection of this compensation and these fines is deferred until the end of the case if the parties bring an action for a negative declaration, for restitution or an ordinary claim, and it lapses for the party who wins that case.
Which court action exists besides the enforcement court?
Even after the periods have passed, the debtor may file an action for a negative declaration of debt (menfi tespit davası) to prove that no debt is owed under İİK Art. 72. In an action filed before enforcement begins, the court may stay the proceedings by interim injunction against security of not less than 15% of the claim; in an action filed after enforcement begins, the proceedings cannot be stayed by injunction, but the debtor may ask that money held at the enforcement office not be paid to the creditor. After payment, an action for restitution (istirdat davası) may arise. For instruments that function as security notes, see also the article on the validity requirements of security notes.
What is the limitation period for a promissory note?
The issuer of a promissory note is liable in the same way as the acceptor of a bill of exchange (TTK Art. 779). Claims against the issuer become time-barred three years after the maturity date (TTK Arts. 778/1-h and 749/1). For cheques, the holder's recourse rights become time-barred three years after the end of the presentment period (TTK Art. 814). The enforcement court examines the limitation objection according to the date on the instrument presented by the creditor; if the creditor cannot prove with an official document or a document whose signature has been acknowledged that limitation was interrupted, the objection is accepted (İİK Art. 169/a).
Which documents are attached to the objection petition?
Depending on the ground, the following documents matter in practice: the payment order and the service record showing the date of service, a copy of the instrument on which the proceedings are based, a bank receipt or signed receipt showing payment, a written document showing that a grace period was granted, and specimen signature documents that may serve for signature examination. The grounds of the objection must be written clearly in the petition; an objection without grounds risks rejection because it does not meet the requirements of the law. The petition should be filed with the enforcement court of the place where the enforcement file is located, not left to the last day, and the date of service should be checked carefully.
Interest, set-off and related topics
For the remedies where interest requested in the proceedings is wrong, see the article on incorrect or incomplete interest claims; for a debtor relying on a counterclaim, set-off (takas) and offsetting (mahsup) should be considered separately. For cheque holders, cheque compensation may also be relevant.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many days does the debtor have to object in a promissory note proceeding?
For a complaint, an objection to the signature and an objection to the debt the period is 5 days from service of the payment order; the period to pay the debt is 10 days (İİK Art. 168).
Where is the objection petition filed?
Petitions for a complaint, an objection to the signature and an objection to the debt are filed with the enforcement court; unlike in ordinary attachment proceedings, an oral or written objection to the enforcement office is, as a rule, not sufficient in this type of proceeding.
Is the attachment lifted if an objection is made in time?
No. The objection does not stop actions other than the sale; the proceedings stop only if the judge orders a temporary stay or accepts the objection.
Can payment of the debt be proved by witnesses?
For the objection to be accepted by the enforcement court, payment must be proved by an official document or a document whose signature has been acknowledged. Otherwise the objection is rejected; the debtor may file an action for a negative declaration in the general court.
What happens if the instrument lacks an element?
If the document lacks the elements of a promissory note, a complaint can be filed within 5 days; the court may also take this into account of its own motion and annul the proceedings (İİK Art. 170/a).
What can be done against a decision rejecting the objection?
An appeal (istinaf) can be filed, but it does not stop enforcement. If the debtor provides security, enforcement stops (İİK Art. 169/a).